New California Legislation Aims to End Unfair 'Crime-Free Housing' Policies

The proposed legislation, AB 1418 by Assemblywoman Tina McKinnor, D-Inglewood, would prohibit cities from forcing landlords to evict renters based on alleged actions at or near the property.

Under current policies, landlords are often required to maintain a “crime-free housing” program in order to receive certain benefits, such as reduced insurance rates or tax credits. These programs often include strict tenant screening processes and lease provisions that allow for the immediate eviction of tenants who are accused of certain criminal offenses, regardless of whether or not they are convicted.

However, critics argue that these policies are unfair, particularly to communities of color and low-income renters who may be disproportionately affected. They say that these policies often rely on vague and subjective criteria, and can result in the eviction of innocent tenants without due process.

Assemblywoman McKinnor’s bill aims to address these concerns by prohibiting cities from requiring landlords to evict tenants based on alleged criminal activity. Instead, it would require that any such evictions be based on a conviction or plea agreement.

The proposed legislation is not without controversy, however. Some opponents argue that the bill would restrict landlords’ ability to maintain safe and secure housing for their tenants. They say that the policy could lead to increased crime and unsafe living conditions for renters.



However, supporters of the bill argue that it is a necessary step towards ensuring fairness and justice for all tenants. They say that the policy would prevent unjust evictions and help to reduce the harmful effects of mass incarceration and the criminalization of poverty.

Regardless of the outcome of the bill, the issue of “crime-free housing” policies is likely to remain a contentious one in California and beyond. As cities continue to grapple with issues of crime and housing, it is important that policymakers consider the needs and rights of all tenants, and work towards solutions that are fair and just for everyone involved.