How to Recognize and Avoid Rental Scams

Kyle Chernetsky • May 14, 2025

Key Takeaways

  • Rental scams have the potential to damage your rental property’s finances and reputation.
  • Knowing how to identify these scams and what to do about them will help protect you and your property.
  • Partnering with a property management company can even further protect your property and finances.


In today’s digital age, landlords have the advantage of reaching a broader audience through online advertising. However, this convenience also opens the door to rental scams that can tarnish your reputation and lead to financial losses. This guide by
C&C Property Management will help you recognize rental scams and educate you on what to do about them to protect your property.


How Rental Scams Typically Unfold

Unauthorized Use of Your Property Listings

Scammers often copy legitimate rental ads, including photos and descriptions, to create fake listings on various platforms. They pose as the property owner, engaging with potential tenants and collecting deposits or application fees. Victims may later discover that the property does not exist or is not available for rent, leading to financial loss and damage to your reputation.​


Requesting Upfront Payment

A common tactic is to demand immediate payment, such as a reservation fee or deposit, to secure the rental. Scammers create a sense of urgency, pressuring prospective tenants to act quickly. Once the payment is made, communication often ceases, and the scammer disappears.​

A person paying for something online.

Tenant Realizes The Scam

After the payment, tenants may attempt to contact the landlord but find it increasingly difficult to reach them, believing this scammer to be the owner of your legitimate rental. Eventually, they realize they have been scammed. This can lead to negative reviews and warnings to others, which can ruin your reputation.


Recognizing The Signs Of A Rental Scam

Being aware of common scam indicators is crucial in protecting yourself and your rental property. Scammers are adept at manipulating situations to appear legitimate, and knowing what to look for can help you address any issues quickly and efficiently. Below are some of the most common red flags to watch for.


Unusually Low Rental Prices

One of the most common tactics used by scammers is offering rental prices that seem too good to be true. If you come across a listing where the rent is significantly below the going rate for similar properties in the area, it’s a major warning sign. 


Scammers typically use these unrealistically low prices to attract attention quickly, creating a sense of urgency for potential tenants. They might also highlight the property's desirable features, like a great location or excellent condition, which further lures victims in.


Lack of Tenant Screening

A key sign that you may be dealing with a scammer is the absence of proper tenant screening procedures. Legitimate landlords typically conduct credit checks, verify employment, and require personal references to ensure their tenants can afford the rent and will respect the property.


A person on a phone call taking notes.

Scammers, however, may skip these important steps to make the leasing process seem easier and faster.


Pressure to Sign Quickly 

Another red flag is if the landlord or agent pressures you to sign a lease agreement quickly without offering a proper viewing or giving you adequate time to ask questions. Scammers often create a sense of urgency, claiming there are multiple parties interested in the property or that you must sign quickly to lock in the deal.


High Reservation Fees

Scammers often ask for large upfront payments under the guise of reserving the rental property. These fees might be presented as "security deposits" or "reservation fees," but they are usually non-refundable and often required before a tenant even sees the property.


Protecting Your Rental Property from Scams

Rental scams are a growing concern, causing financial loss and damaging reputations. By staying vigilant and taking protective measures, property owners can reduce the risk of falling victim to these scams.


Here are several strategies to safeguard your rental property and ensure your business runs smoothly.


Monitor Online Listings Regularly

To protect your rental property from scams, regularly check online platforms for unauthorized listings using your property’s images or descriptions. Scammers often steal photos from legitimate ads to create fake listings and attract potential victims with tempting offers.


A person using a laptop and smiling.

Educate Prospective Tenants

A key way to prevent scams is by educating prospective tenants about your leasing process. Clearly outline your expectations and the steps involved in renting. Make it clear that you always require an in-person property viewing before any payments are made, and remind renters that no legitimate landlord will ask for money before the lease is signed and the property is seen.


Use Watermarked Photos

Scammers frequently steal high-quality property photos to make their fraudulent ads look legitimate. To protect your images, consider adding watermarks. These serve as a visual deterrent, making it more difficult for scammers to use your photos without being traced.


Implement Secure Payment Methods

Scammers often request large upfront payments via wire transfers or cash, which are hard to trace. To protect yourself, specify secure payment methods like credit cards, bank transfers, or trusted online platforms in your listings and lease agreements.


Verify Third-Party Agents

Many property owners hire agents or property management companies to streamline the leasing process. However, scammers may impersonate these professionals and trick you into paying upfront fees for non-existent services. It's crucial to verify the legitimacy of any third-party agents you work with.


Conduct Regular Property Inspections

Regular property inspections are key to maintaining your rental’s quality and security. They allow you to identify any issues with the property or tenants and spot potential risks. If anything seems out of the ordinary, act quickly to investigate and address the problem.


Use a Reliable Property Management Service

For landlords unable to monitor properties closely, partnering with a trusted property management company provides peace of mind. They have the expertise and resources to prevent scams through proactive listing checks, tenant screenings, and secure payment systems.


Protect Your Contact Information

Scammers often pose as tenants, inquiring about the property or requesting a reservation before seeing it. Protect your contact information and use secure communication methods to reduce the risk of scams.


Bottom Line

While online rental marketing increases the risk of scams, landlords can protect their business by hiring a professional team to prevent scams and safeguard their reputation and income. Contact C&C Property Management today for some expert guidance on managing your rental property!

By Kyle Chernetsky May 15, 2025
Being a landlord comes with a lot of responsibilities to keep track of. Here are some of the annual landlord chores you may be forgetting to do.
How to Know if Your Rental Meets Safety Standards
By Kyle Chernetsky May 13, 2025
It’s important to keep your rental property as safe as it can be. Read our full guide here to meeting safety standards with your property rental.
By Kyle Chernetsky April 9, 2025
Discover how to conduct a tenant walk-through inspection with expert tips from C&C Property Management.
More Posts